[knot-dns-users] Re: Change of default nsec3-salt-length

Hello David, the risk of changing the policy only consist by the consequence that the zone's NSEC3s are exchanged all at once, which my cause minor hiccups only for very large zones. For tiny ones this is negligible. Anyway, if you use default settings, your salt is exchanged every month already https://www.knot-dns.cz/docs/3.4/singlehtml/index.html#nsec3-salt-lifetime (which would eventually stop when the salt is zero, because there will be nothing more to change) Unlike DNSSEC key roll-overs, changing salt does (or should) not involve any consideration regarding caching resolvers. In fact, you have third possibility: 3) do nothing and let the salt length have changed by upgrading Knot version To elaborate the two options you mentioned: 1) add explicit salt length 8, live with that and consider changing to 0 manually later on 2) add explicit salt length 0, migrate immediately, and later on when Knot changes the default you might want to remove the option from your conf again My favourite is 2). Hope I helped! Libor PS: I like your train photos On 10. 12. 24 8:47, Erwan David wrote: